To Each His Own (1946)
[6]
Olivia de Havilland won her first Oscar for this sudsy soap opera about a woman who gives up her infant son and spends the rest of her life trying to reconnect with him. The melodrama may be an acquired taste, but no one can steal audience sympathy better than de Havilland. I went with it, happy ending and all. In a neat (and slightly creepy) bit of casting, John Lund plays both de Havilland’s ill-fated lover and her grown-up son.
Academy Award: Best Actress (DeHavilland)
Nominations: Best Original Story